Go with the Epi, Tom... check out Uwe for the confirmation on that... he felt that the Epi had the superior quality on the sound front, by a long stroke... considered the Gibson variant to be very poor, although, iirc, he quite liked the sound of the Shadow, in it's own right, but compared to the Epi...
Chime in please, Uwe, if your about, or I'll dig and find his comments for you, Tom...