A flats vs rounds comparison

Started by Dave W, May 21, 2020, 09:19:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Grog

The Memphis ES Les Paul Bass came from the factory with flat wounds. The only new bass I've bought that was shipped with them.
There's no such thing as gravity, the earth just sucks!!

Dave W

My Vox Spyder came with tapewounds. It was made in '68 and I bought it new in '69. It was an Eko-made bass and Eko sold strings under their own name so I'd guess that was the brand. I never changed them the whole time I owned the bass.

Grog

I'm not sure if the Tape Wounds are any good anymore, but here is a batch of never used Gibson bass strings. (1) Tape Wound, (1) Flat Wound & (1) Round Wound.....

There's no such thing as gravity, the earth just sucks!!

Dave W

Good price for 1998! Why wouldn't the tapewounds be good? The nylon wrap shouldn't deteriorate.

Grog

#19
They must have sat in the store for 25 years. I offered them $10 a pack & they were happy to let them go..... They also had NOS Ripper/Grabber cases in stock at the time.

Nylon coating still looks as new!


There's no such thing as gravity, the earth just sucks!!

Dave W

As I suspected!

I'm surprised Groth had anything around that long. Old stock was the province of Torp's in St.Paul and Suneson's on E. Lake Street.

ilan

Tapewounds often necessitate widening the nut slots, something I don't want to perform on a vintage bass.

Dave W

Quote from: ilan on June 04, 2020, 11:34:29 PM
Tapewounds often necessitate widening the nut slots, something I don't want to perform on a vintage bass.

I've never had to widen a nut slot for tapewounds, the nylon wrap has compressed enough without binding in the slot.

patman

D'addario's and GHS are normal gauges

Grog

The NOS Gibson strings seem to be extra light gauge. .091 E string......
There's no such thing as gravity, the earth just sucks!!

Dave W

Quote from: Grog on June 08, 2020, 06:33:30 PM
The NOS Gibson strings seem to be extra light gauge. .091 E string......

You mentioned that these were years old when you bought them. Back in the 70s, they were probably the only flatwound set Gibson offered.

Bubbalou88

I have been very happy with TI Jazz Flats and LaBella Low Tension Flats (little more tension than TI's but less than most others)
CEO of Retired

Bubbalou88

#27
For the most part I use TI Jazz Flats or LaBella Low tension flats( little higher tension than the TI's)
For rounds I like DR Silver Stars or Black Beauties ( both are thin coated) for less Finger to string noise . If you use a coated string I recommend top loading only as the feed thru the body string ferrules are not typically grounded and might pick up noise
CEO of Retired

tore00

I've a 1967 Guild Starfire and I stringed initially with Thomastick flats. No sustain, maybe because of the high magnetic field of the bisonic pickup. I tried to lower the poles, but no luck. I changed to roundwound and she plays beautiful. Deep, resonant, a great bass. I presented her in this post
http://bassoutpost.com/index.php?topic=10154.15
Maker of the Bad-Sonic Pickups

Bubbalou88

Yep, it is amazing how a string works well on one bass or guitar and not another mostly due to pickup characteristics!
CEO of Retired