So, what have you been listening to lately?

Started by Denis, February 08, 2018, 11:49:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

westen44

I'm sorry to be the one bad apple that spoils the whole bunch.  But a Brazilian band covering Beatles songs and putting a Portuguese spin on it doesn't work for me.  I love Brazil and the Portuguese language.  I love my Brazilian friends.  But this Brazilian band putting a Motown spin on Beatles music doesn't work--despite their great technical skill. I realize that, obviously, a lot of people seem to like this, but I'm never going to be one of them.  I'm sure there must be some Beatles purists who feel even more strongly about this than I do.  But I don't consider myself a purist and don't even revere the Beatles.  In fact, I'm even kind of tired of their music.  Something which possibly makes me even less willing to hear their music sound worse than the original.  I do appreciate Pilgrim's posts, though, even if I don't always agree with them.  He is somebody who actually goes out and does stuff, then tells people about it. 

Pilgrim

Thanks kindly @Westen44.

I sure wouldn't have guessed that the Blues Beatles were from Brazil.  There was no accent in their vocals, and their technical ability is excellent - especially the bass player. Id put him in the top 10 of bass players I've ever seen. I'd never heard of the group. I was surprised by the idea of turning Beatles hits that we've all heard hundreds of times into blue tunes, but I found the execution outstanding!

However, I'm sure it's not everyone's cup of tea. For that matter, the event wasn't either. Two days of nonstop blues is a lot for anyone but a hard core blues fan to stomach, but the venue, a two-day blues jam, was perfect for this group. I only attended one day, and it was enough. I wouldn't categorize their work as better or worse then the originals, simply as different. I might say the same thing about the group Disturbed doing the Sounds of Silence - and I thought the Disturbed version was magnificent, although their other work doesn't appeal to me at all.

It's all good.  I see fewer concerts than many here do, but I am sometimes moved to write about them. This summer I have an Alison Krause concert, and later a John Fogerty concert coming up, and I look forward to both of them.
"A computer lets you make more mistakes faster than any other invention with the possible exceptions of handguns and tequila."

Ken

Also kinda weird in that respect is that the Gypsy Kings are French.

westen44

Quote from: Pilgrim on June 09, 2026, 10:50:53 AMThanks kindly @Westen44.

I sure wouldn't have guessed that the Blues Beatles were from Brazil.  There was no accent in their vocals, and their technical ability is excellent - especially the bass player. Id put him in the top 10 of bass players I've ever seen. I'd never heard of the group. I was surprised by the idea of turning Beatles hits that we've all heard hundreds of times into blue tunes, but I found the execution outstanding!

However, I'm sure it's not everyone's cup of tea. For that matter, the event wasn't either. Two days of nonstop blues is a lot for anyone but a hard core blues fan to stomach, but the venue, a two-day blues jam, was perfect for this group. I only attended one day, and it was enough. I wouldn't categorize their work as better or worse then the originals, simply as different. I might say the same thing about the group Disturbed doing the Sounds of Silence - and I thought the Disturbed version was magnificent, although their other work doesn't appeal to me at all.

It's all good.  I see fewer concerts than many here do, but I am sometimes moved to write about them. This summer I have an Alison Krause concert, and later a John Fogerty concert coming up, and I look forward to both of them.

I'm not to the point that I would call myself a Beatles purist, but maybe I slightly lean in that direction without thinking about it.  I used to be a Beatles fan and maybe I still am to an extent.  But after years of listening to them, I kind of did get sort of tired of listening to their music.  However, I've always had a problem with some people doing covers of the Beatles. Most of the time it doesn't work for me, with a few exceptions, though. 

I really like Disturbed and would love seeing them in concert some day.  I agree their cover of the Sounds of Silence was magnificent.   

I think getting to go to concerts may be more important than some people realize.  It can give you a unique opportunity.  Those outstanding concerts can end up being very important memories that mean something. I don't much like dwelling on the past.  But thinking about concerts you've gone to can be very pleasant.  Also, sometimes that can be something others want to hear about. 

uwe


Does this find your grace? John Lennon said he liked it.
We've taken too much for granted ... and all the time it had grown ...
From techno seeds we first planted ... evolved a mind of its own ...

uwe

I always liked the take(s) of these guys (and I'm a Sgt Pepper nerd) ...




We've taken too much for granted ... and all the time it had grown ...
From techno seeds we first planted ... evolved a mind of its own ...

westen44

Quote from: uwe on June 09, 2026, 09:23:43 PM

Does this find your grace? John Lennon said he liked it.

How much John Lennon liked his own version of "Help" is debatable since it's clear he would have preferred the Beatles version be slower.

For the record, I never said I didn't like Beatles covers at all.  In the case of the Blues Beatles, they've attempted to bend the Beatles music into another genre.  I don't think it fits very well. I've heard about some comments on the Internet in which some Beatles fans are actually unhappy at what the Blues Beatles are doing.  I can only imagine that those are die-hard Beatles fans.  I don't think I quite fit into that category.

As for Deep Purple covers of Beatles songs, this is better than "Help."  I've always thought "We Can Work It Out" must have been written when Paul McCartney was having an off day.  The Deep Purple version is way better, IMO.  Even when I was a teenager, WCWIO was always toward the top of my list of least favorite Beatles songs.  So, yes, the Deep Purple version is genuinely superior.  And the "Help" version is probably at least as good as the Beatles, although probably not better. 


https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=deep+purple+we+can+work+it+out


4stringer77

Merle is the best and Dolly and Porter do a fine job with this song too.
Contrary to what James Bond says, a good Gibson should be stirred, not shaken.