I always thought that a black P w white guard looks like a cheap toy.... this may have something to do with 90% of the shitty Squire Ps I was exposed to as a younger lad were of that fin; they just scream "student instrument" to me. Now white with a black guard; that's classy/classic. Black can be acceptable with a tort guard, as is more common on Js. Black w B/W/B guard is nice too.