Garbage Front woman Calls out Music Industry

Started by westen44, July 04, 2026, 02:53:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

westen44

Shirley Manson of Garbage says we're losing a new generation of musicians. 
NSFW because of profanity. 

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/dEMbze3RDQw


Ken


4stringer77

I would say it's a case of simple economics. Produce something of value and there will be a demand for it. Is there really some hidden hand pushing an agenda to make musicians irrelevant or are times simply changing?
Contrary to what James Bond says, a good Gibson should be stirred, not shaken.

westen44

Well, I can't be sure how right Shirley Manson was.  I like her music, though.  And Scottish accents are cool.  Also, I like the band Garbage a lot.  Shirley Manson, as someone who experienced what it was like being in a successful band, probably does feel some sympathy for young artists out there.  They won't ever get the opportunities she had. 

I just found this video about the music industry being over.  I like his analogy about accepting the reality of the way things are now.  Expecting things to go back the way they were would be like expecting horses as a main form of transportation to come back.

What bothers me is that music in society isn't even half as important as it used to be.  Too many people look at music as background noise.  Not something to propel their lives.  I think maybe Jimi Hendrix might have been seeing this happen even in the late 60s.  But music is being shoved to the back.  I believe Shirley Manson may be right about a generation of young musicians being lost.  Because they will never even be given a chance.  Whose fault it is may be hard to pinpoint. But it does appear to be happening. 

The Music Industry is Over (And It's Not Coming Back)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ceg26TjOjW8

Ken

Hell, we can barely even get much acknowledgment from our peers.  When our album was ready, I was so proud of it and the work we put into it, and was excited to post it over at the TalkBass Thunderbird group, partly because I've been there for over 10 years, and partly because I played my Thunderbird on the whole thing.  The response was so incredibly lukewarm.  Only a tiny handful acknowledged it at all.  And I've heard the same thing from others who have posted original music over there.

westen44

Sometimes cooperation from peers may not be there.  Especially if there is any jealousy or envy involved.  On the other hand, at other times best friends may be people from other bands.  That's another thing I got from researching Shirley Manson.  I get the impression many of her best friends seem to be musicians from other bands that Garbage has toured with through the years.  That's the way it should be, IMO.  But sometimes reality presents a different story. 

I remember the last gig our band played in Ireland many years ago.  We were indie rock.  The other band playing at the venue was punk rock.  Maybe there were some legitimate musical differences involved.  The could have been a factor.  But nobody in their entire band would even speak to me.  I could tell they took themselves very seriously.  Maybe like the next U2.  Certainly, getting acknowledgement from somebody like that was something that wasn't going to be happening.

BTL

Until there is a better alternative to Spotify, people will need to support bands directly for live music to come back.

gearHed289

She's certainly not wrong. The music biz died a couple of decades ago. There's next to zero artist development anymore. I'm glad to be well past the "trying to make it" phase of my playing career. And to add to what Ken was saying, it's hard to get any recognition at all anymore. You have to promote, promote, promote and add content, content, content to have any chance at all. I hate the constant self promotion. I'm seriously questioning putting out new music anymore. The Cyberiam is working on two new songs right now for fall release, but beyond that, I may be done. I have a "not set in stone" plan to leave the band scene entirely at the end of 2027.   

Ken

We really have to just do it for the love of it, because there's no money in it, even with all that work you put in.  And really, as has been said, any support and recognition, other than a handful of friends, is the community with other bands doing similar things. And I do believe what westen44 said about envy being a factor.

gearHed289

Quote from: Ken on July 07, 2026, 09:30:53 AMWe really have to just do it for the love of it, because there's no money in it, even with all that work you put in.  And really, as has been said, any support and recognition, other than a handful of friends, is the community with other bands doing similar things. And I do believe what westen44 said about envy being a factor.

100% I've been saying for a long time - the upside to the biz being on life support is that it helps weed out the poseurs who are more interested in being a star than a musician. Our music is very niche - progressive hard rock. And there is a scene for that. Small, but devoted to supporting music.

Pilgrim

There's a gent named Hank Bordowitz who I met when he was a graduate student taking my online class. I worked with him on his master's paper, and he did a great job on it.

That paper turned into an interesting book: Dirty Little Secrets of the Record Business: Why So Much Music You Hear Sucks.

https://www.amazon.com/Dirty-Little-Secrets-Record-Business/dp/1556526431

If you're interested, it's a good read. Hank has written a half-dozen books about the music industry biz, and he knows his stuff.
"A computer lets you make more mistakes faster than any other invention with the possible exceptions of handguns and tequila."

Ken

Quote from: Pilgrim on July 08, 2026, 11:37:57 AMThere's a gent named Hank Bordowitz who I met when he was a graduate student taking my online class. I worked with him on his master's paper, and he did a great job on it.

That paper turned into an interesting book: Dirty Little Secrets of the Record Business: Why So Much Music You Hear Sucks.

https://www.amazon.com/Dirty-Little-Secrets-Record-Business/dp/1556526431

If you're interested, it's a good read. Hank has written a half-dozen books about the music industry biz, and he knows his stuff.

Cool!  Do you think the info in it is still relevant 20 years later?

Pilgrim

Quote from: Ken on July 08, 2026, 12:14:46 PMCool!  Do you think the info in it is still relevant 20 years later?


It has been a while. I've taught that online course for 18 years and updated it three times. I guess I'd say that if nothing else, it will tell you a lot about how we got "here," wherever that is.
"A computer lets you make more mistakes faster than any other invention with the possible exceptions of handguns and tequila."