2191
Gibson Basses / Re: New SG bass, sounds soo mean, pickups or scale?
« on: February 13, 2010, 09:23:01 PM »
I get a kick out of the term "short scale." 34 inches only intonates the harmonic series of the G-string properly, which is why a lot of Fender basses can sound like total mud otherwise but have an ear-bleeding trebly G-string. The only widely available fretted basses to my knowledge with scale-accurate intonation across all the strings are the Dingwall Voodoo's. Even their Jazz-type bass is still off-scaled to keep the upper harmonics in check so that it will sound like a "traditional" electric bass. Shorter scale basses will always have more fundmanetal relative to the upper harmonics because the string does not have the "proper" period of movement to have an equal harmonic series, hence the Hofner 'boom' that lends itself so well to melodic lines without stepping on the guitars. I don't like 'short scales' personally because I'm a big guy and they feel cramped to me, and their lower relative string tension means I can't dig in as hard as I like to.