The drawback to short scales is that less tension gives you less punch! I always liked the short scale for small club venues and blues atmosphere. I don't know if it was the neck woods or the pickups of the Gibson, but I liked the sounds I got from my Fender Jazz. I When I built the V bass, I was just going for the wow factor and stage [presence with Billy's 58 Korina guitar.
Jack Bruce played a short scale Gibson and sounded great.
Jack Bruce played a short scale Gibson and sounded great.