Quote from: Alanko on January 28, 2025, 01:36:44 PMI don't think magnet type matters unless you know a whole raft of other specs about a pickup. Ceramic magnets don't give a pickup a faster attack and colder tone. Alnico III isn't spongier, etc. if you don't know the magnet and coil geometries then you're in the dark.
Ceramic is perceived as a cheaper magnet and ceramic pickups are perceived as ersatz. I think people hear 'ceramic' and think of cookware, as criticisms tend to be that they are cold/harsh/brittle-sounding pickups. A Dimarzio Model P isn't that cheap (a Tonerider alnico P Bass pickup is far cheaper) and it isn't a bright pickup either.
Well, as much as I dislike 'mystique' around vintage materials, and work more with speaker design than pickups nowdays, you can still have very audible differences between alnico 5 pickups vs a ceramic ones when all other parts are the same. Back when I did pickup repairs in my shop, the most common pickup request (after rewinding broken fender custom shop pickups) was to replace ceramic magnets with alnico 5 in mexican strat pickups. Probably some forum hype firing up this trend, but lots of guitar players were happy with this mod. And quite audible difference.
One can argue that the pickup in question was probably designed for alnico from the beginning, of course.
But obviously the biggest difference between the two materials is the price
