Guitar Aficionado is an attempt to follow in the footsteps of Cigar Aficionado and Wine Spectator, but believe it or not, it's published by the parent company of Guitar World.
I never have quite understood the special appeal of figured maple tops. They are nice when done well, but no nicer than a lot of other hardwoods. Personally, I'd rather have plainsawn walnut. And now, plenty of lower cost Chinese guitars have them, so I can't see why someone would pay a premium anymore.