Ultimately, Dave and PBG hit it on the head. It's all about the player. When I play a modern active PU bass, the first thing I do is fart around for a few minutes and pretend I'm Stanley Clarke, but when it's time to actually play something, I fumble around with the controls and try to dumb it down as much as I can to make it sound like my 51 or 70 P
.
It's funny when the guy who owns the bass is giving me a crash course on how to get more of this and more of that by tweeking in the controls and my only question for him when he is done is, "how do I make it go away"?
Dumbing it down is the only way to get what I like, so for my purposes , I see no need to spend a lot of money on a bass with a lot of features that I don't use or want.
A lot of modern bass players are kind of OK with playing my 70 P but my 51 they absolutely hate because it's too "primitive". I'm very understanding of different opinions and I don't knock anyone for what they like or dislike. I'm pretty used to being a minority and just about anything that comes out of my mouth is not going to be the popular opinion
.
Rick