but the neck was like a baseball bat.
You say it like it's a negative thing...
Ha!...it was just really round and fat front to back.
Sounds right to me. It's supposed to be a Classic Vibe '50s isn't it?...You young pups, why in my day the necks had bark on them.
Nice! I've never played a 50s Fender, but I played a '57 re-issue a few years ago, and the neck was nice and flat. I don't usually care for P necks, but that one was great.