I guess ultimately I choose not to get that deeply into in the minutia of basses. How far is too far? Will every "identical" pickup have exactly the same amount of copper wound around the bobbin? Are all pole pieces uniformly magnetic? Every piece of the same species of wood will be subtly different. The scientist in me says it all must an effect, but I'll freely admit that it's beyond both the capabilities of my ears to hear and my level of interest to care.
It boils down to a simple choice for me - do I like this bass or do I not? The sweat I was wiping out of my headphones says yes to me
Uwe, your comment about "dirty mids" interests me - in my experience it's been harder to get an audible (never mind good) sound in the rehearsal room out of the Victory Artist - it's so refined sounding to me that I had to EQ the hell out of it just to hear myself properly over the band. This spooked me out enough to take a spare with me to the first gig I played the Victory at in case I couldn't get a good sound but it performed great, probably because it was a nicer room and I was using my own amp (which is much better for me than the variable stuff you get in rehearsal rooms)
I realise the contentious comment was "probably the best bass Gibson ever made". That was written in the heat of the moment and should have had opinion disclaimers on it. It's certainly the best bass Gibson ever made in my collection, much as I love all the others
Jules, I'm still a tender novice. I've only been playing properly for 4 years and I've only done 17 gigs. Feeling vibrations while playing? I'm barely remembering to look up now and again and I barely remember any of the time I'm on stage (and not through alcohol - I've got a strict "one pint before" limit). Even in non-pressure playing situations I don't think I've built up enough playing time with enough basses to speak with authority on this matter.
Dave, despite my scoffs I would have a go at A/Bing two identical basses made of different woods. While I'm sure I'd be able to hear a difference, whether or not I'd correctly identify the mahogany one is another matter.